FICTION |
| 2011- Bloodroot by Amy Greene |
| 2010- All the Living by C.E. Morgan |
| 2008- Strange As the Weather Has Been by Anne Pancake |
2007- Refuge by Dot Jackson |
2006- What Travels With Us: Poems by Darnell Arnoult |
| 2005- No award information available |
2004- Saints at the River by Ron Rash |
2003- The Midwife’s Tale by Gretchen Moran Laskas |
2002- No award given |
| 2001- At Home in the Heart of Appalachia by John O’ Brien |
1997- Cold Mountain by Charles Frazier |
| 1992- The Unquiet Earth by Denise Giardina |
| 1988- Fair and Tender Ladies by Lee Smith |
| 1987- Storming Heaven by Denise Giardina |
1984- Last One Home by Jon Ehle Poetry (instituted as a separate category from Fiction Award in 2011) |
| 2011- This Gone Place by Lisa Parker |
Special Weatherford Award Winners |
| 1999- Sidney Saylor Farr and Jerry W. Williamson |
| 1996- Loyal Jones |
| 1988- Alfred Perrin |
| 1985- Albert Stewart, Certificate of Achievement |
| 1979- Cratis Williams |
| 1978- Harriette Simpson Arnow |
| 1977- James Still |
| 1976- Harry Caudill |
| 1975- Jesse Stuart |
| 1973- Wilma Dykeman |
| 1972- Robert Coles, M.D. |
The Wilma Dykeman “Faces of Appalachia” Post-doctoral Research Fellowship was instituted in 2009.
| 2009-2010: Emily Satterwhite |
| 2008-2009: Janet L. Justice-Crickmer |